An international team of researchers, led by scientists from the Department of Astronomy at Stockholm University, has estimated that there are more galactic black holes in the early Universe than astronomers had previously thought. This study was conducted using the Hubble Space Telescope and was published in August 2024 in the scientific journal The Astrophysical Journal Letters.
Scientists do not yet have a thorough understanding of exactly how the primordial giant black holes of the early Universe formed. Many of them, however, had reached a mass at least 1 billion times greater than that of the Sun, and did so relatively early in the course of cosmological evolution. How did they “manage” to gain such an enormous mass so quickly?
The answer to this question remains unclear, and besides, there are still significant uncertainties regarding our understanding of how galaxies evolve. In order to investigate this “co-evolution” of galaxies and the black holes at their cores in greater depth, astronomers used the Hubble Space Telescope, specifically the groundbreaking images from the “Hubble Ultra-Deep Field” (HUDF).
The original HUDF image was created when Hubble's cameras focused on a small region of space in the southern constellation of Fornax, from September 2003 through January 2004. This image captures 10,000 galaxies, the primordial light from many of which traveled as far as 13 billion years to reach us. But how did the authors of the study manage to estimate the number of black holes contained in the galaxies of the early Universe?
The same “window” into the early Universe was observed again by Hubble several years later and was last imaged in 2023. By comparing the relevant near-infrared images taken by Hubble in 2009, 2012, and 2023, astronomers observed that the brightness of some distant galaxies had changed. The reason this happens is that the giant black holes at their cores do not continuously absorb the surrounding matter at a constant rate.
This material forms a rotating disk of gas and dust around each black hole. As the material in the disk spins at ever-increasing speeds, moving ever closer to its event horizon, they superheat to millions of degrees Celsius, emitting radiation. Since, therefore, the rate at which matter is accreted changes over time, the radiation from these active galactic nuclei also changes. It is precisely this change in the radiation from certain active galactic nuclei that can be detected by comparing HUDF images taken at different times. Using this method, astronomers have detected more black holes than had previously been found using other methods.
But how were the first galactic black holes formed? Some astrophysicists, in their attempt to answer the question of the origin of galactic black holes, argue that their primordial “seeds” resulted from the gravitational collapse of the Universe’s first generation of stars, which were truly enormous compared to those that followed and were still “uncontaminated” by heavier metals. Other scientists argue that they formed through the direct collapse gas clouds, or through the successive collisions and mergers of stars in dense stellar clusters, or even that they originated from microscopic primordial black holes, which formed in the first few seconds after the Big Bang. The definitive answer to this question has not yet been found.
However, accurately determining the abundance of giant black holes that existed in the early Universe can be used to evaluate all of these different theories. At the same time, it can improve simulations of galaxy formation and, as a result, lead to a more accurate understanding of their formation and evolution. This study is a step in that direction.
Photo: In the inset of this new HUDF image, one of the supermassive black holes that revealed their existence through changes in their brightness can be seen [Credit: NASA, ESA, M. Hayes (Stockholm University), J. DePasquale (STScI)]